Inconsistent Choices Among Adolescents in El Salvador
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.60758/laer.v34i.326Keywords:
El Salvador, teenagers, inconsistencies, developmental decision-making, field experimentAbstract
This paper examines inconsistencies in the decision-making of a sample of 2,248 adolescents from El Salvador when completing two classic experiments: temporal discounting and risk preferences. Inconsistency in responses is a significant issue when collecting experimental data because it implies a loss of the sample, as these data come from subjects who do not respond to the task as they should and could indicate, for instance, a lack of understanding of the task. To mitigate this problem, we reduced the number of decisions, designed tasks with a strong visual component, and adapted them to the context with the assistance of a local pedagogical team. Despite these adaptations, we first observe participants' significant difficulties in avoiding errors such as multiple switching. Secondly, we investigate whether developmental factors (age), cognitive skills, and task repetition improve consistency. Lastly, we explore whether inconsistency in decision-making somehow shapes their immediate and long-term educational expectations.
References
@article{exadaktylos2013experimental,
title={Experimental subjects are not different},
author={Exadaktylos, Filippos and Esp{'i}n, Antonio M and Branas-Garza, Pablo},
journal={Scientific Reports},
volume={3},
number={1},
pages={1213},
year={2013},
publisher={Nature Publishing Group UK London}
}
@article{henrich2010weirdest,
title={The weirdest people in the world?},
author={Henrich, Joseph and Heine, Steven J and Norenzayan, Ara},
journal={Behavioral and brain sciences},
volume={33},
number={2-3},
pages={61--83},
year={2010},
publisher={Cambridge University Press}
}
@article{brocas2020evolution,
title={The evolution of choice and learning in the two-person beauty contest game from kindergarten to adulthood},
author={Brocas, Isabelle and Carrillo, Juan D},
journal={Games and Economic Behavior},
volume={120},
pages={132--143},
year={2020},
publisher={Elsevier}
}
@article{brocas2020development,
title={The development of social strategic ignorance and other regarding behavior from childhood to adulthood},
author={Brocas, Isabelle and Carrillo, Juan D},
journal={Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Economics},
volume={85},
pages={101524},
year={2020},
publisher={Elsevier}
}
@article{fehr2013development,
title={The development of egalitarianism, altruism, spite and parochialism in childhood and adolescence},
author={Fehr, Ernst and Gl{"a}tzle-R{"u}tzler, Daniela and Sutter, Matthias},
journal={European Economic Review},
volume={64},
pages={369--383},
year={2013},
publisher={Elsevier}
}
@article{sutter2013impatience,
title={Impatience and uncertainty: Experimental decisions predict adolescents' field behavior},
author={Sutter, Matthias and Kocher, Martin G and Gl{"a}tzle-R{"u}tzler, Daniela and Trautmann, Stefan T},
journal={The American Economic Review},
volume={103},
number={1},
pages={510--31},
year={2013}
}
@article{luhrmann2018impact,
title={The impact of financial education on adolescents' intertemporal choices},
author={Lührmann, Melanie and Serra-Garcia, Marta and Winter, Joachim},
journal={American Economic Journal: Economic Policy},
volume={10},
number={3},
pages={309--32},
year={2018}
}
@article{paluck2016changing,
title={Changing climates of conflict: A social network experiment in 56 schools},
author={Paluck, Elizabeth Levy and Shepherd, Hana and Aronow, Peter M},
journal={Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
volume={113},
number={3},
pages={566--571},
year={2016},
publisher={National Acad Sciences}
}
@article{starkey2009identifying,
title={Identifying influential young people to undertake effective peer-led health promotion: the example of A Stop Smoking In Schools Trial (ASSIST)},
author={Starkey, Fenella and Audrey, Suzanne and Holliday, Jo and Moore, Laurence and Campbell, Rona},
journal={Health education research},
volume={24},
number={6},
pages={977--988},
year={2009},
publisher={Oxford University Press}
}
@article{valente2007peer,
title={Peer acceleration: effects of a social network tailored substance abuse prevention program among high-risk adolescents},
author={Valente, Thomas W and Ritt-Olson, Anamara and Stacy, Alan and Unger, Jennifer B and Okamoto, Janet and Sussman, Steve},
journal={Addiction},
volume={102},
number={11},
pages={1804--1815},
year={2007},
publisher={Wiley Online Library}
}
@article{bonan2023prosociality,
title={Prosociality in variants of the dictator game: Evidence from children in El Salvador},
author={Bonan, Jacopo and Burlacu, Sergiu and Galliera, Arianna},
journal={Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Economics},
volume={107},
pages={102084},
year={2023},
publisher={Elsevier}
}
@article{alan2021building,
title={Building social cohesion in ethnically mixed schools: An intervention on perspective taking},
author={Alan, Sule and Baysan, Ceren and Gumren, Mert and Kubilay, Elif},
journal={The Quarterly Journal of Economics},
volume={136},
number={4},
pages={2147--2194},
year={2021},
publisher={Oxford University Press}
}
@article{ugur2021does,
title={Does self-control foster generosity? Evidence from ego depleted children},
author={Ugur, Zeynep B},
journal={Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Economics},
volume={90},
pages={101652},
year={2021},
publisher={Elsevier}
}
@article{cardenas2012gender,
title={Gender differences in competitiveness and risk taking: Comparing children in Colombia and Sweden},
author={C{'a}rdenas, Juan-Camilo and Dreber, Anna and Von Essen, Emma and Ranehill, Eva},
journal={Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization},
volume={83},
number={1},
pages={11--23},
year={2012},
publisher={Elsevier}
}
@article{castillo2020negative,
title={Negative childhood experiences and risk aversion: evidence from children exposed to domestic violence},
author={Castillo, Marco},
year={2020},
publisher={IZA Discussion Paper}
}
@article{moreira2010risk,
title={Risk seeking behavior of preschool children in a gambling task},
author={Moreira, Bruno and Matsushita, Raul and Da Silva, Sergio},
journal={Journal of Economic Psychology},
volume={31},
number={5},
pages={794--801},
year={2010},
publisher={Elsevier}
}
@techreport{munro2014risky,
title={Risky rotten kids: an experiment on risk attitudes amongst adolescents in rural Uganda},
author={Munro, Alistair and Tanaka, Yuki and others},
year={2014},
publisher={Mimeo}
}
@article{khachatryan2015gender,
title={Gender and preferences at a young age: Evidence from Armenia},
author={Khachatryan, Karen and Dreber, Anna and Von Essen, Emma and Ranehill, Eva},
journal={Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization},
volume={118},
pages={318--332},
year={2015},
publisher={Elsevier}
}
@article{fan2000teaching,
title={Teaching children cooperation—An application of experimental game theory},
author={Fan, Chinn-Ping},
journal={Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization},
volume={41},
number={3},
pages={191--209},
year={2000},
publisher={Elsevier}
}
@article{SUTTER201998,
title = {Economic behavior of children and adolescents – A first survey of experimental economics results},
journal = {European Economic Review},
volume = {111},
pages = {98-121},
year = {2019},
issn = {0014-2921},
author = {Matthias Sutter and Claudia Zoller and Daniela Glätzle-Rützler},
keywords = {Children, Experiment, Survey, Social preferences, Time preferences, Risk preferences, Competitiveness, Gender, Age}
}
@article{adelman2016school,
title={School dropout in Central America: An overview of trends, causes, consequences, and promising interventions},
author={Adelman, Melissa A and Szekely, Miguel},
journal={World Bank Policy Research Working Paper},
number={7561},
year={2016}
}
@article{dinarte2023preventing,
title={Preventing Violence in the Most Violent Contexts: Behavioral and Neurophysiological Evidence from El Salvador},
author={Dinarte-Diaz, Lelys and Egana-delSol, Pablo},
journal={Journal of the European Economic Association},
pages={jvad068},
year={2023},
publisher={Oxford University Press}
}
@article{alfonso2023baking,
title={The baking of preferences throughout high school},
author={Alfonso, A and Bra{~n}as-Garza, P and Jorrat, D and Priss{'e}, B and Vazquez, MJ},
journal={mimeo},
volume={},
pages={},
year={2024},
publisher={Elsevier}
}
@article{alfonso2023development,
title={The development of rationality in games with hidden information},
author={Alfonso, Antonio and Brañas-Garza, Pablo and Brocas, Isabelle and Carrillo, Juan D and Gonz{'a}lez, Juan B and Vazquez, Maria Jose and others},
year={2023}
}
@article{gumball,
title={Holt Laury as a gumball machine},
author={Vasco, M and Vazquez, MJ},
journal={mimeo},
volume={},
pages={},
year={2023},
}
@article{alfonso2022testing,
title = {The adventure of running experiments with teenagers},
journal = {Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Economics},
volume = {106},
pages = {102048},
year = {2023},
issn = {2214-8043},
doi = {https://doi.org/10.1016/j.socec.2023.102048},
url = {https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2214804323000745},
author={Alfonso, Antonio and Brañas-Garza, Pablo and Jorrat, Diego and Lomas, Pablo and Prissé, Benjamin and Vasco, Mónica and Vázquez-De Francisco, María J.},
keywords = {Developmental decision-making, Field experiments, Economic preferences, Teenagers},
abstract = {Economists are increasingly interested in how to conduct experiments with teenagers. This paper evaluates whether different methodological factors impact the answers of teenagers to standard experimental tasks on measuring time preferences, risk preferences and cognitive abilities, among others. Results show: (i) the recruitment process matters. When the school includes the experiment as an institutional activity, the dropout rate is observed to be significantly reduced; (ii) brocasthetical payments elicit similar results to monetary payments; (iii) adding visual elements to the experiment’s interface improves the quality of answers; and iv) although the type of device has no effect on the results, who administers the experiment does have an effect. We conclude by giving three suggestions to researchers interested in conducting experiments with teenagers: first, run the experiment as a school-programmed activity; second, the use of actual payments is not necessary, which increases the cost and complicates the recruitment; and third, integrate visual components to the task.}
}
@article{coller1999eliciting,
title={Eliciting individual discount rates},
author={Coller, Maribeth and Williams, Melonie B},
journal={Experimental Economics},
volume={2},
number={2},
pages={107--127},
year={1999},
publisher={Springer}
}
@article{holt2002risk,
title={Risk aversion and incentive effects},
author={Holt, Charles A and Laury, Susan K},
journal={The American Economic Review},
volume={92},
number={5},
pages={1644--1655},
year={2002}
}
@article{delavande2009subjective,
title={Subjective expectations in the context of HIV/AIDS in Malawi},
author={Delavande, Adeline and Kohler, Hans-Peter},
journal={Demographic Research},
volume={20},
pages={817},
year={2009},
publisher={NIH Public Access}
}
@article{branas2021pay,
title={To pay or not to pay: Measuring risk preferences in lab and field},
author={Bra{~n}as-Garza, Pablo and Estepa, Lorenzo and Jorrat, Diego and Orozco, Victor and Rascon Ramirez, Ericka Gabriela},
journal={Judgment and Decision Making},
volume= {16},
pages= {1290 - 1313},
year={2021}
}
@online{laprensagrafica2021,
author = {{La Prensa Gráfica}},
title = {Cuántos homicidios han ocurrido en tu municipio año por año en la última década},
year = {2021},
note = {Accessed: 2023-06-11}
}
@online{iml2021,
author = {{Instituto de Medicina Legal}},
title = {Datos de homicidios en 2021},
year = {2021},
url = {https://transparencia.oj.gob.sv/descargar/3/20791/HOMICIDIOS%20A%25C3%2591O%25202021/11-01-2023},
note = {Accessed: 2023-06-11}
}
@article{amador2021cognitive,
title={Cognitive abilities and risk-taking: Errors, not preferences},
author={Amador-Hidalgo, Luis and Bra{~n}as-Garza, Pablo and Esp{'i}n, Antonio M and Garc{'i}a-Mu{~n}oz, Teresa and Hern{'a}ndez-Rom{'a}n, Ana},
journal={European Economic Review},
volume={134},
pages={103694},
year={2021},
publisher={Elsevier}
}
@article{castillo2011today,
title={The today and tomorrow of kids: Time preferences and educational outcomes of children},
author={Castillo, Marco and Ferraro, Paul J and Jordan, Jeffrey L and Petrie, Ragan},
journal={Journal of Public Economics},
volume={95},
number={11-12},
pages={1377--1385},
year={2011},
publisher={Elsevier}
}
@article{bettinger2007patience,
title={Patience among children},
author={Bettinger, Eric and Slonim, Robert},
journal={Journal of Public Economics},
volume={91},
number={1-2},
pages={343--363},
year={2007},
publisher={Elsevier}
}
@article{filippin2016reconsideration,
title={A reconsideration of gender differences in risk attitudes},
author={Filippin, Antonio and Crosetto, Paolo},
journal={Management Science},
volume={62},
number={11},
pages={3138--3160},
year={2016},
publisher={INFORMS}
}
@article{jacobson2007inconsistent,
title={Inconsistent Choices in Lottery Experiments: Evidence from Rwanda},
author={Jacobson, Sarah and Petrie, Ragan},
year={2007}
}
@article{jacobson2009learning,
title={Learning from mistakes: What do inconsistent choices over risk tell us?},
author={Jacobson, Sarah and Petrie, Ragan},
journal={Journal of risk and uncertainty},
volume={38},
pages={143--158},
year={2009},
publisher={Springer}
}
@article{branas2019cognitive,
title={Cognitive reflection test: Whom, how, when},
author={Bra{~n}as-Garza, Pablo and Kujal, Praveen and Lenkei, Balint},
journal={Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Economics},
volume={82},
pages={101455},
year={2019},
publisher={Elsevier}
}
@article{frederick2005cognitive,
title={Cognitive reflection and decision making},
author={Frederick, Shane},
journal={Journal of Economic Perspectives},
volume={19},
number={4},
pages={25--42},
year={2005}
}
@article{charness2023repeated,
title={Repeated experience and consistent risk preferences},
author={Charness, Gary and Chemaya, Nir},
journal={Economics Letters},
volume={233},
pages={111375},
year={2023},
publisher={Elsevier}
}
@article{ert2017revisiting,
title={Revisiting risk aversion: Can risk preferences change with experience?},
author={Ert, Eyal and Haruvy, Ernan},
journal={Economics Letters},
volume={151},
pages={91--95},
year={2017},
publisher={Elsevier}
}
@article{bandura2001self,
title={Self-efficacy beliefs as shapers of children's aspirations and career trajectories},
author={Bandura, Albert and Barbaranelli, Claudio and Caprara, Gian Vittorio and Pastorelli, Concetta},
journal={Child development},
volume={72},
number={1},
pages={187--206},
year={2001},
publisher={Wiley Online Library}
}
@article{khattab2015students,
title={Students’ aspirations, expectations and school achievement: What really matters?},
author={Khattab, Nabil},
journal={British educational research journal},
volume={41},
number={5},
pages={731--748},
year={2015},
publisher={Wiley Online Library}
}
@article{samara2021can,
title={How can bullying victimisation lead to lower academic achievement? A systematic review and meta-analysis of the mediating role of cognitive-motivational factors},
author={Samara, Muthanna and Da Silva Nascimento, Bruna and El-Asam, Aiman and Hammuda, Sara and Khattab, Nabil},
journal={International journal of environmental research and public health},
volume={18},
number={5},
pages={2209},
year={2021},
publisher={MDPI}
}
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Gladis Herminia Gonzales Aguilar, Adriana Gaviria
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
LAER Copyright and License
Authors submitting articles to Latin American Economic Review (LAER), automatically grant this journal a license to publish. Copyright of all published material remains with the authors, who can reuse it in future work without needing to make reference to LAER. Similarly, any other contribution of material to the website (for example text, photographs, graphics, video or audio) automatically grants us a right to publish. Copyright, however, remains with the author(s).
Authors release their work under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0). This license allows anyone to copy, distribute and transmit the work, provided the use has no derivatives, is non-commercial and appropriate credit to the author(s) is given. (If you remix, transform, or build upon the material, you may not distribute the modified material.)
A human-readable summary of the licence:
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
Full legal text: